Developing a Collaborative, Interdisciplinary Unit
This past week, the faculty at my high school voted on the
topic for what will become a school-wide interdisciplinary unit. The topic chosen was “21st Century
skills: What’s an Education Worth?” Admittedly, I’m not particularly excited
about the topic, but being a government teacher, I can respect any decision
made democratically. To clarify the
topic, the group that suggested this topic explained the unit to be one where
students explore careers in fields related to the subjects they take. The culminating project will be a school
career wiki that includes student videos and writings.
This unit is still very much in the planning phases – we
have yet to even set a date for when the unit will be taught. In preparation for our next collaborative
planning meeting, I feel the need to use this space to ask and answer a few
questions that I think our faculty should consider as we prepare this
interdisciplinary unit.
1. Does
our high school have access to the hardware necessary to make this project
happen? If not, then how will we
acquire/compensate for any inadequacies?
I think our school really needs to
take a very close look at this. The most
useful computers in the building are the freshly replaced laptops issued to
each faculty member. Other computers in
the building are seriously out date. If
we have access to A/V equipment, it would be news to me. Sure, we could rely on students’ access to
technology at home and through their mobile devices. However, I’ve made that assumption once
already this year, and regretted the extra work it added when I had to devise
an alternative assessment because some students had no access to take simple
digital pictures. For this unit to work
successfully, I think we have to be able to ensure that we have the tools
in-house to make this successful.
2.
What
software(s) will be used for students to collaborate and share their pieces of
the project?
Richardson gives numerous examples
of very good wikis and uses for wikis in chapter four of Blogs, Wikis, Podcasts, and Other Powerful Web Tools. Which one will be best for this
project? Will we host the videos on
another site, then imbed them in the wiki?
Will the videos be hosted on www.youtube.com? Will we use another source? What about images?
3.
How
will student collaboration be facilitated?
This question, I think must be
answered before all others, and I fear that right now, this is the
weakest. Administration’s approach seems
to want to leave much room for the individual content areas to develop their
own assessments and criteria for student contributions. Personally, I think a common thematic unit
should also involve a common rubric.
This would be a great opportunity to create discussion on what rigor
really looks like (which is a strong theme throughout many faculty meetings
this year). Teachers, like their
students, learn by doing, and this may be a great tool to improve our craft as
well as create student understanding and learning. If I had it my way, I suggest that content
areas create “production teams,” like you would find at a commercial site
that. Students would contribute in one
of a number of different ways – some may be responsible for acting in a video,
others would be responsible for creative design or written content.
Over all, I think this has the potential to be a really
fantastic project. Now we have to work
out the details.
Wow that sounds like a huge undertaking! My school is also doing a similar project with the 8th graders, however they are not incorporating it across the curriculum. They were all required to take several career surveys, then research some of the careers that were listed. Finally they culminated the project by composing an essay about one career they would choose and the classes or subjects they would need to study in order to accomplish their goals.
ReplyDeleteYou pose some very valid questions about the feasibleness of the project however and the supports it will have. I agree with your position that you should have a similar rubric across the field so that there is no confusion among student or staff about who is responsible for what. I would be interested to hear how your schools project turns out and if the interdisciplinary approach is successful. Great post!